Crime stats or coffee shops? How to spot the world’s most gentrified cities
Crime stats or coffee shops? How to spot the world’s most gentrified cities
Posted by John P. Bradford // October 1, 2016
Researchers worldwide have come up with many innovative ways to make sense of gentrification and perhaps even prevent its worst effects. Douglas Murphy crunches the numbers
Gentrification is a word on many lips. Property values, rent rises, people displacement, speculative development, offshore investment; coffee shops, beards, bikes and vanishing nightlife. In the worlds big cities, gentrification and its discontents have become a cause clbre.
But as that range of complex ideas suggests, gentrification is also a notoriously slippery concept. Is it a purely economic process, or is it culturally driven? Is every deprived neighbourhood that experiences an influx of wealthy residents an instance of gentrification? Must the change occur organically, or can governments gentrify areas according to a plan?
In the half-century since Ruth Glass first employed the term to describe the return of the London middle classes to Victorian properties previously subdivided into slums sociologists, geographers, economists and anthropologists have all struggled to agree on a coherent and transferable definition of the politically loaded G-word.
In recent years, however, increasing amounts of data and the ability to overlay divergent phenomena has led to studies that try to make sense of what is sometimes described as a phantom concept. By understanding and measuring the process, some believe it may be possible to alleviate the most damaging effects of gentrification: the impoverishment and displacement that frequently accompany it.
The most fundamental evidence for gentrification comes from the cost of property. Rapid increases in the cost of buying or renting a house, above rises in income, are clear signs of a rapid change in the urban character of a neighbourhood.
Last year, NYUs Furman Center prepared a report on New York City, source of much of the rhetoric around gentrification, that charted changes in rental value from 1990-2010.